Michaels Return Policy: Return Window, Refunds, Receipts, and Exceptions

The Michaels return policy allows customers to return many eligible arts, crafts, framing, and home décor purchases within 60 days, provided the items meet the retailer’s return conditions. Most qualifying purchases require proof of purchase, and the merchandise generally must be new, unused, and in its original packaging.

However, not every Michaels product follows the standard return rules. Custom framing, clearance merchandise, seasonal products, and certain specialty items may have additional restrictions or different return requirements.

This guide focuses on Michaels stores and purchases in the United States. It explains how to return online and in-store purchases, what happens when you lose your receipt, how refunds work, and which products require extra attention before requesting a return.

Michaels Return Policy at a Glance

The standard return period does not guarantee that every item will qualify. Product-specific restrictions and the terms attached to the original purchase can affect eligibility.

Understanding the Michaels Return Policy

Michaels generally provides a 60-day return period from the purchase date for eligible products purchased directly from the retailer.

The policy applies to qualifying merchandise purchased in Michaels stores and through Michaels.com, although the return procedure differs depending on how the item was purchased.

To qualify for an ordinary return, the product generally must be:

• New and unused.
• In its original packaging.
• Within the applicable return period.
• Accompanied by a receipt or eligible purchase record, or meet the requirements for a return without a receipt.
• Outside any category that is excluded from returns.

Defective merchandise may qualify for different treatment, depending on the product.

When Does the 60-Day Return Period Start?

Michaels states that its standard return period begins on the purchase date, rather than automatically beginning when the item is delivered.

For example, if an eligible product was purchased on October 1, its ordinary 60-day period would be measured from that purchase date.

Customers ordering online should check their order details to identify the correct purchase date and avoid confusing the delivery date with the return deadline.

Michaels Return Windows by Product Category

Not every Michaels purchase is eligible for the same return period.

These distinctions matter because some categories have shorter deadlines, while others are subject to completely different remedies.

Cricut Products

Cricut products have stricter return requirements than ordinary craft supplies.

Michaels requires Cricut products to have unopened packaging and a receipt to qualify for returns or exchanges.

If a Cricut product develops a defect during its manufacturer’s warranty period, the customer generally must contact the manufacturer rather than return it through Michaels, except where the law requires otherwise.

Opening a Cricut machine before deciding whether to keep it can therefore affect return eligibility.

Glowforge Machines and Filters

Eligible Glowforge machines and filters have a 14-day return period from purchase.

A qualifying return requires a receipt and a sealed, unopened box.

Certain Glowforge products, including specified Pro and Plus machines and the Compact Air Filter, cannot be returned at a Michaels store. Customers must contact Michaels Customer Care to initiate the appropriate return.

Opened-box troubleshooting and manufacturer warranty concerns follow a separate support process.

Custom Framing

Michaels custom framing orders have a special rework provision.

Customers may request that a custom framing order be reworked at the same Michaels store within 14 days of pickup.

This is not the same as a general promise that a completed custom frame can be returned for a full refund.

Customers who discover an issue with frame dimensions, materials, or workmanship should contact the original store promptly and explain the problem.

Classes and Party Reservations

Michaels also publishes separate cancellation conditions for certain services.

Classes are refundable up to the class start date.

Party reservations can be canceled for a refund when the cancellation occurs at least seven days before the scheduled party. Cancellations within seven days are not refundable under the stated policy.

What Condition Must Returned Items Be In?

For standard returns, Michaels requires merchandise to be new, unused, and in its original packaging.

This is especially important for craft supplies, equipment, decorative merchandise, and products that may lose resale value once opened or used.

Customers should preserve the original packaging and keep all components together until they are certain they want to keep the purchase.

Can You Return Opened Items to Michaels?

Opened products do not automatically qualify for returns.

For ordinary merchandise, Michaels requires the item to remain new and unused in its original packaging. Some categories impose stricter requirements.

For example:

• Cricut products must have unopened packaging.
• Glowforge products covered by the special return provision must remain sealed and unopened.
• Opened trading cards cannot be returned.
• Defective merchandise may be handled under different rules.

Customers should not assume that an opened craft machine or partially used supply is returnable simply because it was purchased within 60 days.

Can You Return Used Craft Supplies?

Ordinary used craft supplies generally do not meet Michaels’ standard new-and-unused condition.

For example, partially consumed paint, used adhesive, or cut and used materials may fail the condition requirement.

If a product was defective when purchased, explain the defect rather than requesting an ordinary change-of-mind return.

Exceptions and Non-Returnable Items

Several categories are excluded from the ordinary Michaels return policy.

Clearance Merchandise

Michaels treats clearance sales as final.

Clearance merchandise is sold as-is and is not eligible for ordinary refunds or exchanges.

This is different from an item that was simply purchased during a promotion or with a coupon.

A discounted regular-price product is not necessarily a final-sale product.

Cut Fabric

Fabric sold as cut fabric is final sale, whether purchased online or in store.

Michaels does not ordinarily accept returns or exchanges for these purchases, except where required by law.

Customers should confirm fabric measurements, material type, and quantity before purchasing.

Gift Cards and Prepaid Cards

Michaels gift cards and prepaid cards cannot ordinarily be returned or exchanged.

Exceptions may apply when required by law.

This rule concerns returning the gift card itself. It does not mean that merchandise originally purchased using a gift card is automatically non-returnable.

Trading Cards

Opened trading card products are considered damaged under Michaels’ return policy and are not returnable.

Customers purchasing collectible card products should inspect the packaging and confirm the correct item before opening it.

How to Return an Item to Michaels

Michaels supports in-store returns for qualifying purchases and an online return process for eligible Michaels.com orders.

The appropriate method depends on the original purchase channel and seller.

Returning an Item In Store

For an eligible store purchase:

1. Gather the merchandise and original packaging.
2. Bring your receipt or other available purchase information.
3. Visit a Michaels retail location.
4. Present the item for return processing.
5. Follow the applicable refund procedure.

Michaels generally permits eligible store purchases to be returned at any Michaels location within the standard return period.

If you do not have your receipt, the store may attempt to locate the transaction using qualifying purchase information.

Returning a Michaels Online Order

Michaels provides an account-based process for eligible online returns.

1. Sign in to your Michaels account.
2. Open your Order History.
3. Select View Details for the relevant order.
4. Find the Return option under the Need Help section.
5. Select the products you want to return.
6. Provide the return reason and item condition.
7. Submit the request.
8. Follow the return instructions supplied for that order.

The online process determines the applicable return procedure and provides information about the next steps.

Customers who checked out without creating an account can use Michaels’ order-tracking process and create an account to begin a return.

Can You Return Online Purchases In Store?

Yes. Eligible merchandise purchased directly from Michaels.com can generally be returned to a Michaels store.

However, products sold by third-party Marketplace or MakerPlace sellers cannot be returned in Michaels retail stores.

Certain specialty products may also have channel-specific restrictions.

Can You Return Store Purchases by Mail?

No. Michaels states that purchases made in its physical stores cannot be returned through its online return process.

Customers should bring eligible store purchases to a Michaels location.

Michaels Return Policy Without a Receipt

Michaels may process qualifying returns without the original receipt, but additional conditions apply.

The retailer first attempts to locate proof of purchase using available transaction information.

For store purchases, Michaels may attempt a receipt lookup using the credit or debit card used during the transaction.

Michaels Rewards information can also assist with locating qualifying purchases.

What Happens If Michaels Cannot Find Your Receipt?

If a receipt cannot be located, Michaels requires a valid photo ID for a return without a receipt.

Accepted identification includes specified government-issued identification, such as a qualifying driver’s license, state-issued identification card, passport, or U.S. military identification.

The retailer records identification information for refund authorization and fraud prevention.

Under the published receiptless-return rules:

• The refund value is based on the item’s lowest selling price during the previous 90 days.
• The refund may be issued on a Store Return Card.
• Merchandise exchange may also be available under the applicable store policy.
• Michaels reserves the right to limit returns or exchanges.

For example, an item originally purchased for $25 could receive a lower return value if its lowest selling price during the relevant 90-day period was less than $25.

The actual amount depends on Michaels’ price records.

Can Michaels Rewards Help Find a Receipt?

Yes. Michaels may use a Michaels Rewards number to help locate qualifying purchases.

This can be useful when the original paper receipt is missing.

However, membership does not guarantee that every transaction can be recovered or that an otherwise ineligible product becomes returnable.

Michaels Online vs. In-Store Returns

The main differences concern return initiation and purchase verification.

Customers should identify whether Michaels itself or a third-party seller fulfilled the order before choosing a return method.

Michaels Marketplace and MakerPlace Return Policy

Third-party purchases are not automatically covered by the same return rules as merchandise sold directly by Michaels.

Michaels operates third-party selling arrangements through Marketplace and MakerPlace.

These sellers can have their own return requirements.

Marketplace Returns

Customers returning a Marketplace purchase must initiate the return through their online account.

The process generally involves opening the order and selecting the option to create a return.

Michaels states that Marketplace returns initiated through this process receive a prepaid UPS shipping label for sending the product directly to the seller.

The applicable seller policy determines whether the item qualifies.

MakerPlace Returns

MakerPlace sellers can establish their own return policies.

Seller options include:

• No returns.
• 30-day returns.
• 60-day returns.

A seller may also apply an individual return policy to a specific product.

This is particularly important for personalized or custom-made merchandise.

Customers initiate a MakerPlace return through their online account. Once the seller approves the request, the seller coordinates the return.

MakerPlace customers are responsible for return shipping costs under Michaels’ stated return process.

Can Third-Party Purchases Be Returned In Store?

No. Michaels states that Marketplace and MakerPlace products are not eligible for in-store returns.

Customers must follow the applicable seller’s online return process.

Michaels Return Shipping Fees and Other Charges

Return costs depend on the type of order and the return method.

For eligible in-store returns, Michaels does not publish a standard separate return-processing charge in its general policy.

For online returns, the procedure and applicable costs should be reviewed when the return request is submitted.

The retailer does not publish one universal mail-return fee that applies to every ordinary Michaels.com purchase.

MichaelsPro Returns

MichaelsPro purchases have their own authorization requirement.

Qualifying purchases may be refunded within 60 days, but a Return Authorization is required.

Customers must obtain authorization through the MichaelsPro support process.

Michaels also states that restocking fees may apply to MichaelsPro returns.

The policy does not establish one universal restocking fee for every MichaelsPro order.

Are Original Shipping Charges Refunded?

Michaels states that original shipping and handling charges may be deducted from the refund unless the return results from an error by Michaels.

This means customers should distinguish between the merchandise refund and the amount originally paid for delivery.

For example, returning an eligible item because it is no longer wanted may not result in reimbursement of the original shipping charge.

If Michaels shipped an incorrect item, the customer should report the error through Customer Care.

Michaels Refund Methods and Processing Times

Michaels generally issues refunds through the original payment method, subject to several exceptions.

The appropriate sales tax is included in qualifying refunds.

Refund Methods by Payment Type

Check Purchases

Michaels applies a 10-day waiting period to returns involving purchases paid by check.

Check purchases returned within that period may be refunded using a Return Card.

Affirm Purchases

Customers who paid using an Affirm virtual card may receive a refund through that card if it remains available in their digital wallet.

If the virtual card is unavailable, Michaels states that the refund may be processed to an alternative debit or credit card.

Customers who cannot provide an alternative card should speak with store management about the available options.

How Long Does a Michaels Refund Take?

Michaels does not provide one guaranteed refund-processing timeframe covering every payment type and return method in its general return policy.

For online returns, the return submission process provides information about the next steps and refund timing.

The overall wait can involve return shipment, inspection or processing, and payment-provider posting.

Customers should keep their return confirmation and contact Customer Care if the refund has not arrived within the timeframe provided for their specific return.

Does Michaels Offer Exchanges?

Michaels’ published policy distinguishes between store exchanges and online exchange requests.

For Michaels.com returns, the retailer states that direct exchanges are not currently offered through its online return process.

Customers who want a different item should return the original eligible product and place a new order.

For qualifying purchases made in physical stores, Michaels’ store return policy refers to returns or exchanges within 60 days.

However, special restrictions apply to certain products, including Cricut merchandise, clearance items, and final-sale products.

Damaged, Defective, or Incorrect Items

Customers who receive a damaged, defective, or incorrect item should contact Michaels Customer Care.

The retailer states that it can assist with replacement or refund requests involving incorrect or damaged deliveries.

What If Your Online Order Arrives Damaged?

If an order arrives damaged:

1. Keep the product and its packaging.
2. Photograph the damage and any affected packaging.
3. Locate the order confirmation.
4. Contact Michaels Customer Care.
5. Explain the damage and request the applicable remedy.
6. Follow the instructions provided for the specific order.

Photographs can help document the problem, although the standard policy does not establish a universal photo requirement for every claim.

What If a Craft Machine Stops Working?

A defective craft machine may be subject to manufacturer warranty rules rather than the ordinary return process.

For example, Cricut products damaged or found defective during the manufacturer’s warranty period generally must be handled through the manufacturer, except where required by law.

Glowforge also has specific troubleshooting and manufacturer-support requirements.

Customers should check the product’s warranty documentation before shipping expensive equipment.

Michaels Gift Returns and Gift Card Purchases

Michaels provides a Store Return Card for qualifying returns involving purchases made with a gift card or accompanied by a gift receipt.

This differs from the standard original-payment refund method.

Can You Return a Gift to Michaels?

A qualifying gift may be returned when it meets the applicable merchandise and proof-of-purchase requirements.

A gift receipt can support the return and generally results in a Store Return Card rather than a refund to the gift recipient’s personal payment card.

If no gift receipt is available, the receiptless-return requirements may apply.

Can You Get Cash Back for a Gift Card Purchase?

Michaels generally issues a Store Return Card when returning eligible merchandise purchased with a gift card.

The gift card itself is ordinarily non-returnable, except where required by law.

Michaels Sale, Clearance, and Final Sale Returns

It is important to distinguish a promotional discount from a final-sale designation.

An eligible product purchased using a coupon or during a regular promotion is not automatically excluded from the standard return policy.

Clearance merchandise, however, is explicitly final sale.

Customers should review the product’s return terms rather than assuming that all discounted merchandise has the same restrictions.

Michaels Holiday Return Policy

Michaels’ standard policy generally provides 60 days for eligible purchases, but a special seasonal restriction applies to online-only costumes and accessory kits.

These items must be returned at least seven days before the applicable holiday.

For other holiday merchandise, customers should check the specific product’s eligibility and any published seasonal terms.

A universal extended holiday return deadline for the 2026 holiday shopping season is not established in the general policy reviewed here.

Customers should not assume that purchases made during November or December automatically receive an extension into the following year.

Does Michaels Rewards Extend the Return Window?

Michaels Rewards can help with purchase identification and receipt lookup.

However, the general return policy does not establish an automatic extension of the standard 60-day return period for all Michaels Rewards members.

The main practical benefit for returns is the possibility of locating qualifying transactions through membership records.

Membership does not override final-sale restrictions or category-specific deadlines.

Michaels Return Policy vs. Manufacturer Warranty

A return policy and a manufacturer warranty serve different purposes.

A return policy determines whether merchandise can be returned under the retailer’s rules.

A manufacturer warranty may provide repair, replacement, or another remedy for a qualifying defect under separate terms.

For certain Cricut and Glowforge products, manufacturer support is particularly important because Michaels imposes specific return restrictions.

Customers should keep purchase documentation for equipment even after the ordinary return window expires.

What Happens If the 60-Day Return Window Has Passed?

A product outside its applicable return period may no longer qualify for an ordinary return.

Michaels does not guarantee that customers can receive refunds after the published deadline.

If the return period has expired, review whether the issue involves a manufacturer defect, warranty coverage, or another applicable legal remedy.

Customers should not rely on an assumed exception or manager approval.

How to Track Your Michaels Return and Refund

Customers who initiate online returns can review the relevant return details through their Michaels account.

The return process provides information about the next steps and refund timing.

For a mailed return, retain the carrier tracking information and drop-off confirmation.

For an in-store return, keep the return receipt until the refund has been completed.

These records are useful if the return requires additional customer-service assistance.

Common Reasons Michaels May Deny a Return

A return may be denied when the purchase does not satisfy the applicable policy.

Common policy-based reasons include:

• The standard or category-specific deadline has passed.
• The merchandise has been used.
• The item does not meet original-packaging requirements.
• The product belongs to a final-sale category.
• A Cricut or Glowforge product fails its special return conditions.
• Required purchase verification cannot be completed.
• A third-party item is presented for an in-store return.
• The request conflicts with the applicable Marketplace or MakerPlace seller policy.

Michaels also reserves the right to limit returns or exchanges.

What to Do If Michaels Denies Your Return

If your return is refused, first ask which policy requirement prevented the return.

Check the original purchase date, product category, condition, and seller information.

If proof of purchase is the issue, ask whether the transaction can be located through the original payment card or Michaels Rewards information.

If the item was sold by a third-party seller, follow that seller’s designated process.

For a defective product, review the manufacturer warranty or contact the appropriate support team.

How to Contact Michaels About a Return

Customers who need help with return eligibility, online return processing, or an incorrect shipment can contact Michaels Customer Care.

Michaels Customer Care: 1-800-MICHAELS (1-800-642-4235).

Michaels also provides customer-support chat through its official website.

For MichaelsPro return authorization, the published dedicated support number is 1-833-MIKEPRO (1-833-645-3776).

Have your order number, receipt, and product information ready before contacting support.

Tips for a Smoother Michaels Return

A few practical precautions can help prevent avoidable return problems.

• Keep the receipt or digital order confirmation until you are satisfied with the purchase.
• Avoid opening Cricut or Glowforge packaging before confirming that the product meets your needs.
• Check clearance labels before purchasing.
• Confirm whether an online item is sold by Michaels or a third-party seller.
• Retain packaging and components for products you may return.
• Start online returns before the applicable deadline.
• Save shipping tracking information and store return receipts.
• Contact Customer Care promptly if an order arrives damaged or incorrect.

These precautions are especially useful for expensive equipment, custom purchases, and items with stricter return conditions.

Read Next

Explore more helpful guides from this category.

View More Articles→

New Balance Return Policy →

Floor and Decor Return Policy →

Jcpenney Return Policy →

Stockx Return Policy →

Free People Return Policy →

Ssense Return Policy →

Frequently Asked Questions

How Many Days Do You Have to Return Something to Michaels?

Most eligible merchandise purchased directly from Michaels can be returned within 60 days of purchase. Certain products, including Glowforge equipment, custom framing services, and seasonal costumes, have different requirements.

Can I Return Something to Michaels Without a Receipt?

Yes, qualifying returns may be possible without a receipt. Michaels attempts to locate the original purchase. If the receipt cannot be found, valid photo identification is required, and the refund may be based on the item’s lowest selling price during the previous 90 days.

Can I Return an Online Michaels Order to a Store?

Yes. Eligible purchases sold directly by Michaels.com can generally be returned at a Michaels location. Marketplace and MakerPlace purchases are excluded from in-store returns.

Can I Return an Opened Cricut Machine to Michaels?

Michaels requires Cricut products to have unopened packaging and a receipt for returns or exchanges. Defective products within the manufacturer’s warranty period generally must be handled through the manufacturer, except where required by law.

Can I Return Clearance Items to Michaels?

No. Michaels clearance merchandise is final sale and is not eligible for ordinary returns or exchanges.

How Long Does Michaels Take to Refund Money?

There is no single guaranteed processing period covering all returns. Online return instructions provide information about refund timing, and the payment method may affect when the money becomes available.

Can I Exchange an Item at Michaels?

Qualifying store purchases may be eligible for exchange under the store return policy. Michaels does not currently offer direct exchanges through its online return process; online customers should return the eligible item and place a new order.

Can I Return a Michaels Gift Card?

Michaels gift cards and prepaid cards are generally non-returnable and non-exchangeable, except where required by law. Eligible merchandise purchased with a gift card may be returned under the applicable merchandise policy, with the refund issued on a Store Return Card.

Conclusion

The Michaels return policy generally allows customers to return eligible merchandise within 60 days of purchase, provided the items are new, unused, and in their original packaging.

Important exceptions apply to Cricut products, Glowforge equipment, custom framing, clearance merchandise, cut fabric, and certain seasonal purchases. Marketplace and MakerPlace orders also follow separate return procedures.

Before requesting a refund, check the purchase date, item condition, original seller, and proof-of-purchase requirements. Keeping receipts, packaging, and return confirmations can make the process easier.

For the most reliable outcome, initiate your return within the applicable deadline and follow the instructions provided for your specific purchase.